The High Court is presently hearing a case brought before it by the Union movement and the various States challenging the new IR laws.
The nub of the case is that the Commonwealth has exceeded its Constitutional powers in introducing the new Work Choices legislation. In the final analysis the case will not turn on whether the legislation is fair or reasonable. Either the Commonwealth had the power to make the IR laws or it did not.
Underlying all of this is a more critical question - Federalism and how the country ticks. There are all the constant arguments and carping about lack of funds in the States to run hospitals and schools, etc. etc. Of course the Commonwealth reaps the benefit of all that GST it collects - and then doles out to the States.
The nub of the case is that the Commonwealth has exceeded its Constitutional powers in introducing the new Work Choices legislation. In the final analysis the case will not turn on whether the legislation is fair or reasonable. Either the Commonwealth had the power to make the IR laws or it did not.
Underlying all of this is a more critical question - Federalism and how the country ticks. There are all the constant arguments and carping about lack of funds in the States to run hospitals and schools, etc. etc. Of course the Commonwealth reaps the benefit of all that GST it collects - and then doles out to the States.
As Professor George Williams says in his piece on Perspective on ABC Radio National last night:
"A battle has been running all year between the State and federal governments over the distribution of GST revenue worth 39 billion dollars. The latest salvos have included hundreds of thousands of dollars spent on TV and newspaper ads by the federal and NSW governments.
While this debate has great financial consequences, it masks the larger problem. It is just one symptom of our dysfunctional federal system."
As Williams also says:
"We need to fix our federal problems. In doing so we need to ask ourselves what should be the role of the States more than a century after we brought about our Federation."
Read the entire thought-provoking and relevant piece [you can also download it from the ABC on line if you want] here.
Comments