Israel has, rightly, attracted criticism for building, and allowing to be built, settlements in the West Bank.
Needless to say the usual suspects have attacked those calling for a cessation of the building and expansion as anti-Israeli etc. Forget that such building is in contravention of the Oslo Peace Accord [?] and undertakings said to have been given by Israel to cease the expansion of settlements on what is after all Palestinian land.
It is therefore refreshing to read this week's editorial "Settlement Freeze" in Forward", a Jewish weekly newspaper published in New York:
"A rash of reports coming out of Israel indicates that a spurt of new construction is under way in Israeli settlements in the West Bank. The development should be alarming to anyone who cares about Israel’s welfare. It’s a violation of Israel’s public commitments, most of all to the Bush administration. It’s damaging to Israel’s international standing and harmful to its security, both short and long term. Most troubling, it’s a sign of the weakness of the Olmert government, and it raises questions about Israel’s ability to negotiate for the peace that its prime minister so clearly wants.
Settler spokesmen and their allies on the right are claiming that the reports were trumped up by the left-wing Peace Now in order to embarrass the settlers and the Israeli government. But that’s simply not true. The reports come from the hawkish Shas party as well as Peace Now, from the conservative Jerusalem Post as well as the liberal Ha’aretz. Some reports, in fact, have come from Prime Minister Ehud Olmert himself, apparently in a bid to soothe his right-wing opponents and keep Shas from bolting his coalition."
Needless to say the usual suspects have attacked those calling for a cessation of the building and expansion as anti-Israeli etc. Forget that such building is in contravention of the Oslo Peace Accord [?] and undertakings said to have been given by Israel to cease the expansion of settlements on what is after all Palestinian land.
It is therefore refreshing to read this week's editorial "Settlement Freeze" in Forward", a Jewish weekly newspaper published in New York:
"A rash of reports coming out of Israel indicates that a spurt of new construction is under way in Israeli settlements in the West Bank. The development should be alarming to anyone who cares about Israel’s welfare. It’s a violation of Israel’s public commitments, most of all to the Bush administration. It’s damaging to Israel’s international standing and harmful to its security, both short and long term. Most troubling, it’s a sign of the weakness of the Olmert government, and it raises questions about Israel’s ability to negotiate for the peace that its prime minister so clearly wants.
Settler spokesmen and their allies on the right are claiming that the reports were trumped up by the left-wing Peace Now in order to embarrass the settlers and the Israeli government. But that’s simply not true. The reports come from the hawkish Shas party as well as Peace Now, from the conservative Jerusalem Post as well as the liberal Ha’aretz. Some reports, in fact, have come from Prime Minister Ehud Olmert himself, apparently in a bid to soothe his right-wing opponents and keep Shas from bolting his coalition."
Comments