The now infamous situation and case of Dr Haneef stands as clear condemnation of former PM Howard and his Immigration Minister, Kevin Andrews. Their behaviour in all of this can only be described in one word - disgraceful! And this from men trained in the law.
Hadley Thomas, writing in The Australian, justly won the Walkely Award this year for his clear expose of the way the whole Haneef case was conducted by the Commonwealth Government.
With the Full Federal Court yesterday ruling that the decision of the original judge was correct, Thomas today reflects on the Haneef case and its implications in a piece "Let us reject guilt by association":
"The concept of guilt by association, adopted with great relish by the Howard government and its immigration minister, Kevin Andrews, in the Haneef case, is again exposed for what it is: deeply flawed, unjust and un-Australian.
As a result of the unanimous judgment by the Full Bench of the Federal Court yesterday, four out of four experienced and distinguished judges have concluded that Mr Andrews went overboard when he used the Migration Act to cancel the visa of Mohamed Haneef.
The judges set out in 50 pages what many people would regard as plain common sense - the trashing of an otherwise blameless individual's rights and freedoms by lumping them with the alleged misdeeds of distant relatives living on the other side of the world is repugnant. We now know it is also unlawful."
Hadley Thomas, writing in The Australian, justly won the Walkely Award this year for his clear expose of the way the whole Haneef case was conducted by the Commonwealth Government.
With the Full Federal Court yesterday ruling that the decision of the original judge was correct, Thomas today reflects on the Haneef case and its implications in a piece "Let us reject guilt by association":
"The concept of guilt by association, adopted with great relish by the Howard government and its immigration minister, Kevin Andrews, in the Haneef case, is again exposed for what it is: deeply flawed, unjust and un-Australian.
As a result of the unanimous judgment by the Full Bench of the Federal Court yesterday, four out of four experienced and distinguished judges have concluded that Mr Andrews went overboard when he used the Migration Act to cancel the visa of Mohamed Haneef.
The judges set out in 50 pages what many people would regard as plain common sense - the trashing of an otherwise blameless individual's rights and freedoms by lumping them with the alleged misdeeds of distant relatives living on the other side of the world is repugnant. We now know it is also unlawful."
Comments